Great present! I agree that some advice is a bit extreme. I see it as a bit of tough love to shock you into reflecting on your behaviour. The main message of the book seems to be: Grow Up. Be professional. And it spells out what that looks like. I believe so many academics are deprived of the hows, and that’s why I recommend the book.

I may write another post on ‘c.v. -building’ as I don’t believe it leads to fulfilment or even the ‘best’ career outcomes. But as a first step I agree with Kelsky that thinking strategically about your publications and other professional activities is a good idea.

The book has many valuable lessons indeed and is honest.
Some points are taken to the extreme a bit, e.g. ‘avoid other PhD candidates at a conference’. The point is nevertheless valid: approach interesting career scholars at a conference to your benefit. That’s always a good idea indeed.

Last point: sometimes it’s also good to do things that give you energy, even if they don’t result in a valuable line on your CV. I have just returned from teaching at a summer school for students which will do nothing for my CV; but I have certainly come back inspired and enthusiastic!

Thanks for bringing this book to our attention, Amber.